| Platinum | George's Cafe |
| Gold | Jim's Burger Haven |
| Silver | Rockabillies |
| Bronze | School House Kitchen and Libations |
| Top Pick | Bad Daddy's Burger Bar |
| Top Pick | Lot One |
| Top Pick | Malone's Clubhouse Grill |
| Top Pick | McDonald's |
| Top Pick | Mighty Burger |
| Top Pick | Original Hamburger Stand |